In the process of planning out the comic I’ve been working on, I have been trying to commit to a medium to actually produce the comic in.  When I first thought of doing a comic, I wanted to do it all in traditional media, Bristol, pencils, inks, etc.  Then, after reading about so many artists digital workflows I thought, “hey, lets try to do it digital”, at least for the inks.  So I whipped out Photoshop, scanned in some pencils I had done for character designs and started doing some tests, with less than stellar results.  I think some of those early failures was simply me not having the experience necessary to “ink” in Photoshop.

I didn’t realize it then, so I went to something else and tried “inking” in Illustrator.  I got better results mostly because Illustrator smoothed out my shaky lines.  I thought “great, I can ink in Illustrator and I’ll have easy to scale line art!”.  Only problem is, Illustrator is the most artist unfriendly piece of software on the planet.  It’s interface just doesn’t make sense (don’t believe me, without looking in the manual or using the help, or Googling, find the toggle that will make a brush stroke maintain it’s transparency setting, go ahead, I’ll wait). Plus the more I worked with it, the more I realized it made my stuff too clean.  I did get to the point where I was even sketching in Illustrator, but I just wasn’t happy with the final product.

I thought about going completely traditional again.  Then I gave Photoshop another chance just the other day.  I started just doing some pencils in it, using some of the lessons I learned from Illustrator (zooming in close is your best friend).  Wonder of wonders, I was enjoying myself and more importantly, getting results I like.  I haven’t tried inking yet but I think I’ll have better luck this time.  I’m even thinking of doing the comic in a more painterly style rather than the traditional black lines and shiny color.

Then again… maybe I’ll just draw it all on bristol and ink it with a brush.